Comments on: Adaptations From Another Perspective http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/2008/11/11/adaptations-from-another-perspective/ Sheesh Y'all, It's More Than Just Anime Wed, 17 Mar 2010 01:25:49 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.5.1 By: Stifler http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/2008/11/11/adaptations-from-another-perspective/#comment-19730 Stifler Wed, 12 Nov 2008 03:46:18 +0000 http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/?p=2133#comment-19730 True - if the animated or even live action adaptation of a certain manga or game doesn't fit the image or feel that I have from the original media, I tend to feel...well, "dissatisfaction" is putting it mildly. Take a certain Tsukihime anime that doesn't exist, for example. If I haven't played the game, I would probably have enjoyed it alot more. Or Rosario Vampire. My friends who haven't read the manga all seemed to like it, through I thought it was horrible compared to the manga. I understand your point about ignoring the fact that you have experienced the original work before, but as you yourself have said, it can be...hard. lol True - if the animated or even live action adaptation of a certain manga or game doesn’t fit the image or feel that I have from the original media, I tend to feel…well, “dissatisfaction” is putting it mildly.

Take a certain Tsukihime anime that doesn’t exist, for example. If I haven’t played the game, I would probably have enjoyed it alot more. Or Rosario Vampire. My friends who haven’t read the manga all seemed to like it, through I thought it was horrible compared to the manga.

I understand your point about ignoring the fact that you have experienced the original work before, but as you yourself have said, it can be…hard. lol

]]> By: Hynavian http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/2008/11/11/adaptations-from-another-perspective/#comment-19700 Hynavian Tue, 11 Nov 2008 18:05:50 +0000 http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/?p=2133#comment-19700 It's the same here for me. I like to compare the manga version Vs anime version Vs Live Action version (if there's any) and that always spoil my enjoyment. Hence, I tend to pick one version and not catch the others. If I'm to catch the various versions, I would just close an eye or both when things differ and start screaming when things are catastrophically different (Eg: Characters live and happily walk away as though nothing happened...think the ending of Claymore anime versus Claymore manga now). :( It’s the same here for me. I like to compare the manga version Vs anime version Vs Live Action version (if there’s any) and that always spoil my enjoyment. Hence, I tend to pick one version and not catch the others. If I’m to catch the various versions, I would just close an eye or both when things differ and start screaming when things are catastrophically different (Eg: Characters live and happily walk away as though nothing happened…think the ending of Claymore anime versus Claymore manga now). :(

]]> By: フェイダムさん http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/2008/11/11/adaptations-from-another-perspective/#comment-19686 フェイダムさん Tue, 11 Nov 2008 11:21:50 +0000 http://www.furuanimepanikku.com/?p=2133#comment-19686 Gotta love that "idiot watching" picture. I need a t-shirt which says that. Gotta love that “idiot watching” picture. I need a t-shirt which says that.

]]>